Melissa Barrera is Carmen and Paul Mescal is Aidan in "Carmen." (Photo courtesy of Goalpost Pictures/Sony Pictures Classics)
“Carmen” is a film of ravishing surfaces and bodies in motion, and that's where its pleasures lie. How much you enjoy it will likely depend on how much you don't mind that its relationship with the source material that inspired it is casual, to put it mildly, and the topical urgency of its setting is relegated to a picturesque backdrop.
The name of the ill-fated gypsy girl originated in Prosper Mérimée's 1845 novella and popularized by Georges Bizet's opera carries baggage that may create a series of expectations among fans that the Sony Pictures Classics release, which premiered locally during the 40th Miami Film Festival back in March, cannot begin to fulfill. The scheming seductress that has captivated audiences for well over a century has been reimagined as a Mexican woman trying to escape a bloodthirsty drug cartel.
As played by the suddenly ubiquitous Melissa Barrera (“In the Heights,” the more recent “Scream” movies), this “Carmen's” Carmen is a good person with killer survival instincts and a reluctance to let strangers in.
Enter Aidan, a U.S. Marine vet who crosses paths with the protagonist when a border crossing in the dead of night takes a sudden violent turn. Aidan, played by Irish actor Paul Mescal in his first high-profile role since his Oscar-nominated turn in “Aftersun,” is stoic and grounded. His moral compass unfailingly points due north, even when making a seemingly impossible split-second choice. But despite his training, he finds himself in over his head as a fugitive without a roadmap, with a hostile companion who wants nothing to do with him.
Paul Mescal in a scene from "Carmen." (Photo courtesy of Goalpost Pictures/Sony Pictures Classics)
At least not at first. It's clear where this road movie is headed, and if one thing is never in doubt, it's that Carmen and Aiden will drop their defenses. Director Benjamin Millepied, a dancer turned choreographer turned music video director making his feature directing debut, spells things out in clear, simple terms. The dialogue, credited to Millepied, Loic Barrere and Alexander Dinelaris, is spare, all the better to devote more screen time to “Carmen's” real highlights: its sunbaked vistas and its dynamic dance sequences. The contemporary dance routines are so good that one begins to wish the entire story was told that way, much like Jacques Demy conceived “The Umbrellas of Cherbourg” as a musical where every line is sung.
Melissa Barrera and Paul Mescal in a scene from "Carmen." (Photo courtesy of Goalpost Pictures/Sony Pictures Classics)
But there's an aesthetic tango going on in “Carmen.” Yes, it's lush and lyrical, but it's also gritty in the way it drops elements of a lovers-on-the-lam narrative into landscapes that would feel right at home in a Ridley Scott movie. An introductory sequence featuring Carmen's mother (Marina Tamayo) dancing the flamenco as an act of defiance gives off early Baz Luhrmann vibes. Millepied's approach suggests the movie that Spanish director Carlos Saura could have made if he'd taken a crack at adapting “They Live by Night,” Nicholas Ray's tender noir romance, and setting it in the present day. Kudos to cinematographer Jorg Widmer (“A Hidden Life”) for bringing these disparate visual elements together so seamlessly.
Rossy de Palma plays Masilda, Carmen's godmother. Carmen is played by Melissa Barrera in the directorial debut of Benjamin Millipied's "Carmen." (Photo courtesy of Goalpost Pictures/Sony Pictures Classics)
Primary colors take over the screen once Carmen and Aiden reach Los Angeles and the nightclub owned by Masilda, Carmen's godmother, played by Almodóvar regular Rossy de Palma. The nightclub setting shows Millepied thriving in his element, as he incorporates Christian iconography that he'd interspersed in the Mexico scenes and lets the power of dance dictate the ebb and flow of the (still rather slim) story.
The scenes between Barrera and de Palma suggest that Millepied, who is married to actress Natalie Portman, ought to consider giving his own spin to a women's melodrama as one of his next projects. And credit is due to composer Nicholas Britell (“Moonlight,” HBO's “Succession”) for going his own way when creating the music that accompanies Carmen and Aiden throughout their flight to freedom.
The director still needs to work out a few kinks, though. Just when you think “Carmen” will launch into an elaborate climactic confrontation as its central characters try to outrun the long arm of the law, Millepied slams on the brakes. Instead, he settles for a rushed, vaguely unsatisfying resolution that feels underdeveloped and half-baked.
Melissa Barrera in a scene from "Carmen." Goalpost Pictures. ©Courtesy of Sony Pictures Classics.
The sparks between Barrera and Mescal may be somewhat muted, but the stars have an easy rapport and look good together, a virtue in a movie of arresting style but limited substance. The goodwill they engender goes a long way toward roping you into their star-crossed odyssey. “Carmen's” destination may not quite measure up to what it promises, but this is still a journey well worth taking.
“Carmen” is showing at O Cinema South Beach and at Coral Gables Art Cinema starting Saturday, May 13.